AWS RDS vs. DynamoDB vs. Aurora: Choose Best Database for Your Application

AWS RDS (Relational Database Service)

Legacy relational database enterprises: Move existing apps based on MySQL, PostgreSQL, Oracle, SQL Server, and MariaDB without code changes.
SMBs developing web applications: Standard CRUD applications with medium traffic requiring relational consistency and ACID support.

Example
A financial institution moved its Oracle database from on-premises to RDS Oracle to make operations easier and adhere to compliance needs.

DynamoDB

Startups requiring quick, scalable NoSQL databases: DynamoDB is the best for applications with key-value or document data models.
Enterprises operating large-scale, low-latency applications: E-commerce sites, game backends, and IoT applications utilize DynamoDB for millisecond response times.

Example
A large e-commerce company utilizes DynamoDB for its shopping cart, providing single-digit millisecond latency for millions of concurrent users.

Amazon Aurora

Large businesses require relational databases with ultra-scalability and availability.
SaaS businesses and high-transaction volume applications seeking enterprise-class relational databases with distributed architecture.

Example
A worldwide ride-sharing service uses Aurora MySQL for its booking application because of high availability (99.99%), automatic scaling, and regional replication.

AWS RDS

A managed relational database service that supports SQL-based engines: MySQL, PostgreSQL, Oracle, SQL Server, and MariaDB. AWS manages provisioning, backups, and scaling.

Key Features

• Multi-AZ deployments for high availability.
• Automated backups and patching.
• Read Replicas for scalability.
• Supports vertical scaling by instance size increase.

Example
A university hosts its student registration system on RDS PostgreSQL, taking advantage of read replicas during enrollment spikes.

DynamoDB

A managed NoSQL database with single-digit millisecond performance at any size. It's optimized for key-value and document-based data.

Key Features

• Serverless: Zero provisioning or scaling required.
• Global tables for multi-region replication.
• Auto-scaling and on-demand capacity modes.
• DAX (DynamoDB Accelerator) for caching.

Example
A game company stores player session information and leaderboards using DynamoDB to handle millions of real-time reads/writes.

Amazon Aurora

A relational database engine that is MySQL and PostgreSQL compatible, providing up to 5x performance over regular MySQL and 3x over PostgreSQL.

Key Features

• Storage replication across 3 AZs for high availability.
• Aurora Serverless for on-demand.
• Global Databases for replication across regions.
• Automated point-in-time recovery and backups.

Example
A media streaming service employs Aurora PostgreSQL for content metadata storage with global replication and fault tolerance.

AWS RDS

• When your application needs relational database features, complex joins, transactions, and referential integrity.

• Legacy application migrations without code modifications.

• Applications that need vertical scaling instead of distributed workloads.

Example
A logistics firm migrated its inventory management system to RDS SQL Server, which required stored procedures and complex transactions.

DynamoDB

• When your application needs low-latency, high-throughput workloads at any scale.

• Schema-less, NoSQL applications, such as IoT, e-commerce, and gaming.

• When auto-scaling and serverless features are must-haves.

Example
A ride-hailing app employs DynamoDB for real-time tracking of driver locations, handling millions of writes per second with predictable performance.

Aurora

• When you require high availability and automatic failover for business-critical workloads.

• SaaS applications with multi-tenancy, regional replication, and automated scaling requirements.

• Applications outgrowing conventional RDS scalability.

Example
A fintech company operating a payment gateway selected Aurora MySQL due to its scalable reads, multi-AZ failover, and ACID compliance.

AWS RDS

Suits well in conventional 3-tier architectures, monolithic apps, and legacy migrations that need ACID compliance.

Example
An HR app utilizes RDS PostgreSQL as the backend database for employee records management with guarantees of data integrity and transaction reliability.

DynamoDB

Built for serverless, event-driven systems and real-time use. Often used with Lambda, API Gateway, and Cognito for backendless applications.

Example
A banking mobile app utilizes DynamoDB for user sessions and transaction logs to provide real-time notifications and a horizontally scalable backend.

Aurora

Suited for modern microservices systems, SaaS applications, and high-traffic transactional systems requiring relational support with horizontal scaling.

Example
A travel booking site operates its reservation database on Aurora PostgreSQL, taking advantage of auto-scaling read replicas and global databases for multi-region configurations.

AWS RDS

• Streamlined management for relational databases.

• Integrated backups, failover, and monitoring.

• Supports a broad set of legacy apps.

• Cost-effective for low-to-medium scale relational workloads.

Example
An e-learning platform hosts its course catalog and enrollment backend on RDS MariaDB, reducing operational expenses without compromising reliability.

DynamoDB

• Millisecond latency with infinite scaling.

• Serverless architecture, no infrastructure management required.

• Pay-per-use with on-demand scaling.

• Perfect for high-speed, low-latency apps.

Example
A social media application stores user posts, likes, and comments in DynamoDB, servicing millions of simultaneous requests without performance issues.

Aurora

• Enterprise-class relational database with 5x MySQL/3x PostgreSQL throughput.

• Serverless and Global Database capabilities.

• Auto-healing storage and instant failover.

• Ideal for high-volume OLTP and SaaS applications.

Example
A video conferencing platform utilizes Aurora Serverless v2 for scheduling meetings, providing scalability and availability under heavy traffic.

Step 1: Get Familiar with Your Data Model

• Relational? Use RDS or Aurora.

• NoSQL / Key-Value / Document? Use DynamoDB.

Step 2: Evaluate Scalability Requirements

• High concurrency and worldwide deployment? DynamoDB or Aurora Global Databases.

• Moderate, repeatable workloads? RDS.

Step 3: Assess Consistency and Transaction Demands

• High consistency and transactional complexity? Aurora or RDS.

• Eventually consistent is OK? DynamoDB.

Step 4: Plan for Management Burden

• Serverless with no management effort? DynamoDB or Aurora Serverless.

• Managed but instance selection needed? RDS or Aurora Provisioned.

Best Practices

• For DynamoDB: Use DAX to cache reads and enhance latency.

• For Aurora: Apply Auto Scaling Read Replicas for high read traffic.

• For RDS: Apply Multi-AZ for failover and read replicas for scaling.

Example
A health data platform used Aurora Serverless for HIPAA-compliant management of patient records, providing scalable workloads and high availability without operator intervention.

Use Case 1: Multi-Database Needs in an E-Commerce Platform

Problem

An e-commerce business requires a relational database for orders and payments, a NoSQL database for product catalogs, and a horizontally scalable architecture for high traffic.

Solution

• Aurora MySQL for payment and order processing (ACID compliance).

• DynamoDB for product catalogs and user sessions (low-latency reads).

• RDS PostgreSQL for legacy inventory systems.

Outcome

• Better scalability and availability.

• 60% less query latency.

• Streamlined database management across workloads.

Use Case 2: Fintech SaaS Platform

Problem

A fintech SaaS application needs multi-region capability, transactional consistency, and serverless scalability.

Solution

• Aurora Global Database (PostgreSQL) for financial transaction processing across regions.

• DynamoDB for audit logs and session storage.

• Aurora Serverless v2 for billing and reporting modules.

Outcome

• Achieved 99.99% availability.

• Improved operational complexity by 50%.

• Enabling real-time data access for compliance and reporting.

1. Which is more cost-effective: RDS, DynamoDB, or Aurora?

DynamoDB is pay-per-use but expensive at high data volumes.
RDS is less expensive for deterministic workloads.
Aurora Serverless provides cost savings for non-deterministic workloads.

Example:
A small SaaS company saved money by adopting Aurora Serverless for intermittent user behavior over RDS provisioned instances.

2. Can I shift from RDS to Aurora?

Yes. Aurora MySQL/PostgreSQL is RDS MySQL/PostgreSQL compatible, simplifying migration.

Example:
A financial company moved RDS MySQL to Aurora MySQL for better performance and availability.

3. Is DynamoDB ACID compliant?

Yes. DynamoDB supports ACID transactions across items and tables.

Example:
An online game utilizes DynamoDB ACID transactions to update user scores and rankings securely.

4. Does Aurora support cross-region replication?

Yes. Aurora Global Database supports low-latency cross-region reads and disaster recovery.

Example:
An internationally based social network site employs Aurora Global Databases for multi-region publishing and replication.

5. Will DynamoDB displace relational databases?

No. DynamoDB is NoSQL and optimized for key-value or document loads. It doesn't have complicated joins and SQL-style relations.

Example:
A customer relationship application stores user profiles in DynamoDB but deploys reports through Aurora.

6. Is Aurora Serverless suitable for production?

Yes. On-demand scaling, fractional ACUs, and high availability make Aurora Serverless v2 production-capable.

Example:
A mobile application backend is based on Aurora Serverless v2, scaling out with demand.

7. How do I get these databases secured?

IAM, KMS encryption, VPC, and security groups apply universally across all three services.
DynamoDB uses fine-grained access controls.
Aurora and RDS have SSL encryption.

Example:
A health app secures Aurora PostgreSQL with encryption at rest/in transit, VPC isolation, and IAM authentication.

8. Can I use all three in one architecture?

Yes. Utilize RDS for legacy applications, DynamoDB for low-latency storage, and Aurora for mission-critical workloads.

Example:
A logistics SaaS platform utilizes RDS Oracle for legacy billing, DynamoDB for tracking shipments, and Aurora for its primary dashboard.

9. How do I monitor these databases?

Use Performance Insights, CloudTrail, and CloudWatch for monitoring and troubleshooting.
DynamoDB provides auto-scaling metrics.
Aurora and RDS offer Enhanced Monitoring.

Example:
A travel agency enhanced query performance by utilizing Aurora Performance Insights to identify slow queries.

Selecting between AWS RDS, DynamoDB, and Aurora hinges on your application requirements, scalability needs, and data model. Each service is well-suited to different types of workloads. Knowing the differences will guide you in developing robust, scalable, and affordable cloud applications.

Are you ready to optimize your AWS database architecture?
Reach out to us today for a complimentary consultation on how to select the best AWS database solution for your applications!