AWS App Runner vs. ECS vs. Lambda: Selecting the Proper Compute Option

Primary Users

• App Runner:
  Developers who want to deploy containerized web applications and APIs fast without having to deal with infrastructure use it the most. It is best suited for teams that want a completely managed service for web application deployment.
  
• ECS:
  Cloud architects and DevOps teams handling containerized applications that need advanced orchestration use it. ECS is best for applications that need total control over container networking and management, as well as big deployments.
  
• Lambda:
  Developers seeking a serverless, event-driven compute service for APIs, microservices, or async workloads. Lambda is also a widely adopted option for stateless functions to respond to events from AWS services, external events, or HTTP requests.

Example:

AWS App Runner

AWS App Runner is a fully managed service intended to make running web applications and APIs easier. Developers can deploy code or containerized applications straight from source code repositories or container images. App Runner handles the management of infrastructure behind the scenes, making it an excellent option for teams who care about building and deploying applications but do not want to be bogged down with server management.

Key Features:

• Automatically deploys and runs applications from source code or container images.

• Supports web applications and APIs.

• Scalable with auto-scaling and load balancing built in.

• Easy to set up with no infrastructure to manage.

Example:

A retail business deploys its product catalog and checkout API using AWS App Runner. App Runner automatically scales based on traffic spikes for promotions.

Amazon ECS

Amazon Elastic Container Service (ECS) is a container orchestration service that is fully managed and lets you run and manage Docker containers at scale. ECS provides flexibility and control over deploying and running containerized applications, and it supports both EC2-backed instances and AWS Fargate (serverless compute for containers).

Key Features:

• Supports both EC2-based instances and Fargate.

• Provides fine-grained control over container orchestration, networking, and storage.

• Works well with other AWS services (e.g., ELB, CloudWatch, VPC).

• Ideal for large-scale applications requiring custom orchestration.

Example:

A gaming company uses ECS to run microservices for their multiplayer game backend, ensuring that players experience minimal downtime and fast matchmaking due to ECS's robust scalability and orchestration.

AWS Lambda

AWS Lambda is a serverless computing service that lets you execute code in response to events without provisioning or managing servers. It's optimized for event-driven workloads and suited best for applications that have to process data, trigger workflows, or respond to HTTP requests without worrying about managing infrastructure.

Key Features:

• Serverless: There is no server management needed.

• Automatically scalable to process millions of requests per day.

• Works with a range of event sources, including S3, SNS, DynamoDB, and HTTP requests through API Gateway.

• Ideal for short-lived, stateless applications.

Example:

A social media application uses AWS Lambda to handle user-uploaded videos by resizing them automatically and applying watermarks whenever new material is uploaded to an S3 bucket.

AWS App Runner

Use AWS App Runner when you require:

• A managed platform for web app and API deployment.

• An infrastructure management abstraction solution.

• Scaling automatically, with no load balancing to configure.

Best Use Cases:

• Small or medium-sized web apps and APIs that need little setup.

• Development teams or startups that need rapid deployments.

• Apps that do not need sophisticated container orchestration or customized networking.

Example:

A blogging platform deploys its web app rapidly using App Runner and manages fluctuating traffic without human intervention.

Amazon ECS

Use ECS when you require:

• Complete control over the deployment and orchestration of containers.

• A scalable environment for executing containerized applications.

• Flexibility in workload management with fine-grained control over networking, storage, and security.

Best Use Cases:

• Microservices applications require sophisticated orchestration.

• Massive, multi-container applications with high customization requirements.

• Containerized applications call for control over the underlying infrastructure.

Example:

A streaming platform leverages ECS to orchestrate its backend microservices, servicing massive-scale video ingestion, processing, and delivery all over the world.

AWS Lambda

Apply Lambda when:

• You require serverless computing with automatic scaling.

• Low-overhead, event-driven applications without servers to manage.

• Short-running functions that act upon events or data without keeping a persistent state.

Optimal Use Cases:

• Event-driven data processing.

• Real-time file processing or data transformation (resizing images, logging processing, etc.).

• Backend web and mobile application services (e.g., invoking workflows on HTTP requests).

Example:

A weather forecasting app utilizes Lambda to analyze data from IoT sensors, execute analytics, and create real-time weather forecasts.

AWS App Runner, ECS, and Lambda find their place in various areas of AWS architectures based on the requirements of the application:

• App Runner best applies in simplicity-and-fast-deployments top-of-mind architecture such as web services and API-based apps.

• ECS applies best in architecture needing microservices with individual needs of orchestration and effective management of the containers, delivering all compute control to users.

• Lambda best applies to serverless, accommodating event-based workload and offering no need to manage the server, scaling by default.

Example 1:

A social media site employs App Runner for its user authentication API, ECS for backend microservices handling user posts, and Lambda for image upload and real-time notifications.

Example 2:

A financial institution employs ECS for containerized services handling risk analysis, Lambda for processing transactions, and App Runner for hosting an API to offer real-time alerts.

AWS App Runner

• Simplicity: Ideal for teams that do not wish to deal with infrastructure.

• Auto-scaling: Scales automatically per the traffic requirements.

• Managed Service: Easy to deploy and manage with low operational overhead.

AWS ECS

• Flexibility: Offers complete control over your containers.

• Large-scale Operations: Suitable for containerized applications that need high-level control of deployment and networking.

• Integrated with AWS services: Integrates well with services such as VPC, IAM, and ALB.

AWS Lambda

• Serverless: No infrastructure to manage.

• Event-driven: Ideal for applications that respond to real-time events and don't require a persistent state.

• Cost-effective: Only pay for the compute time you use, with automatic scaling with demand.

1. Assess Application Requirements:

   • Is your app containerized? ECS could be the ideal choice.

   • Do you require a fully managed service that requires little setup? Try App Runner.

   • Is your application serverless or event-driven? Lambda is probably your go-to choice.

2. Evaluating Scaling and Flexibility:

   • Do you need infrastructure and custom orchestration management? ECS.

   • Do you need quick scaling without the management of infrastructure? Lambda or App Runner.

3. Evaluating Cost:

   • For light and straightforward applications, Lambda or App Runner may be cheaper than ECS, particularly for small workloads.

4. Evaluating Complexity:

   • ECS is suited for sophisticated applications with full orchestration control of the container.

   • App Runner is perfect for developers who want a quick, easy containerized web app deployment.

Use Case 1: E-Commerce Platform Scaling

Problem:
A web-based e-commerce platform must scale its checkout API rapidly to handle seasonal traffic spikes.

Solution:

• App Runner is utilized to deploy and scale the API with ease based on traffic.

• API performance is continuously monitored by CloudWatch, which automatically scales resources.

Outcome:

• Fast, scalable deployments with no downtime during peak events.

• Smooth deployment of a new version of the app during Black Friday sales.

Use Case 2: Microservices for Video Streaming

Problem:
A video streaming business must be able to handle microservices for video encoding, content delivery, and analytics.

Solution:

• ECS is utilized for handling backend services and deploying microservices in the form of containers.

• Lambda is responsible for real-time notification of new content availability.

• CloudWatch tracks service health and sends alerts.

Outcome:

• The video streaming service operates smoothly with auto-scaling.

• Ongoing monitoring provides high availability and low downtime.

What is the distinction between AWS App Runner and ECS?

• App Runner is for basic app deployments and hides infrastructure, whereas ECS gives complete control of container management and orchestration.

2. When do I use AWS Lambda instead of ECS?

• Use Lambda if you require event-driven, serverless compute for transient workloads, and ECS for sophisticated, long-running containerized applications.

3. Is AWS Lambda suitable for microservices?

• Yes, Lambda is suitable for microservices, but it is best suited for small, stateless services and not for large-scale microservices with complex orchestration.

4. How do the pricing models of AWS App Runner, ECS, and Lambda differ?

• App Runner and Lambda are more economical for light, short-duration workloads, whereas ECS could be more expensive because of the requirement for dedicated EC2 instances.

5. Am I able to run containerized workloads on AWS Lambda?

• Yes, it is possible to use AWS Lambda with containerized workloads, but ECS is better for sophisticated, production-grade container orchestration.

6. Is AWS ECS compatible with Kubernetes?

• Yes, AWS ECS is compatible with Kubernetes via EKS (Elastic Kubernetes Service) to deploy and scale containerized workloads.

7. How does AWS App Runner scale my applications?

• App Runner dynamically scales your application according to traffic, so performance is guaranteed during high traffic.

8. Is AWS Lambda appropriate for real-time data processing?

• Yes, Lambda is well-suited for real-time data processing because it can scale automatically and react to events in near real-time.

9. What is the ideal compute choice for a microservices-based architecture?

• ECS is the most suitable option for large-scale microservices architectures, providing full control over container orchestration and networking.

Choosing the right AWS compute service—App Runner, ECS, or Lambda—depends on the complexity, scalability needs, and nature of your workloads. Whether you’re running lightweight web applications, complex containerized services, or serverless functions, AWS provides the perfect tool for every need.

Ready to scale your applications with the right AWS compute option?
Contact us today for a free consultation on how to choose and implement the best AWS computing service for your business needs!